New Car Replacement Insurance: Everything You Need to Know

New car replacement insurance covers the cost to replace your brand-new car if a crash occurs. To qualify for this type of policy, you typically must also have comprehensive and collision insurance on a brand-new vehicle. Under the terms and conditions of your policy, your insurance company will cover a brand-new version of the same make and model if you total the car within the first one to three years after purchase.

Buying a brand-new car has lots of benefits. However, it can also be costly, as a vehicle can lose as much as 10% of its value when you drive it off the lot. Getting new car replacement insurance is an effective way to ensure you’ll be able to purchase another vehicle if you total your new car.

What Is New Car Replacement Insurance?

New car replacement insurance reimburses you for the vehicle’s full value in case an accident damages it beyond repair. Some policies are only valid during the first year of ownership, but others extend to two or three years and cover other situations, such as vehicle theft or a natural disaster.

If something happens to your car while you have new car replacement insurance coverage, your insurance company will reimburse you for the cost of the same make and model, minus any applicable deductibles.

This type of insurance isn’t mandatory in any state. Providers usually require you to first get both collision coverage, which reimburses you for vehicle repairs from an accident regardless of who’s at fault, and comprehensive coverage, which protects your vehicle from other issues, such as theft, environmental damage, and vandalism.

How Does New Car Replacement Insurance Work?

The best way to explain how this type of insurance works is with an example, so let’s consider the following scenario. After years of being frugal, avoiding any unnecessary expenses, and working hard, you can finally afford your dream car: a Mercedes-Benz E-Class E 350 4MATIC. It sets you back around $60,000, but the feeling of pure comfort and luxury is priceless.

Everything’s going great until a few months later when the unthinkable happens: a pickup truck rams into you and totals your new car. No one gets hurt, but your insurance company will only reimburse you for your vehicle’s current value, which is around $53,000. This means you’ll have to dip into your savings once again if you want a brand-new car identical to the one that was just totaled.

If you had new car replacement insurance, your insurance company would have reimbursed you for the full price of a brand-new Mercedes-Benz E-Class E 350 4MATIC, minus your deductible.

What are Some of the Benefits of New Car Replacement Insurance?

When deciding whether new car replacement insurance is appropriate for your situation, you should consider its potential benefits. Some common ones are:

It Protects You against Vehicle Depreciation

We’ll start with the most obvious one. The purpose of this type of insurance is to protect you from losing money in case something happens to your car within the first few years of ownership. The exact gap between your car’s initial price and estimated value when you total it varies depending on multiple factors. Still, it can be significant, so this extra coverage can make financial sense.

It Gives You Peace of Mind

As with many different types of insurance, new car replacement insurance can be money well spent even if you don’t use it. This type of coverage can help ease your mind by knowing that, even if something happens and your prized possession is wrecked, you can get one just like it without spending more money.

It’s Relatively Inexpensive

The exact cost of new car replacement insurance varies based on multiple factors, such as your insurance carrier, driving history, and vehicle type. It usually increases your insurance policy cost by 5-10%, meaning you’ll likely pay a few hundred dollars extra for it. While this increase isn’t negligible, it may be a lot less than your new vehicle’s depreciation rate over the first few months of ownership.

How Can You Determine Whether You Need New Car Replacement Insurance?

While getting new car replacement insurance for your new vehicle can be a good idea, some situations can make it more or less worthwhile. It’s probably a good idea to get it if you fit one of these criteria:

  • Your new car is expensive. Paying more for insurance for a new $17,000 car makes less sense than doing so for a $50,000 one. When deciding whether new car replacement coverage is a good idea for your situation, you should determine whether the difference between the car’s initial cost and its value after a few months is worth the higher insurance premium.
  • You face a higher-than-usual risk of getting into an accident. The likelihood of getting in a serious car accident can depend on many factors, such as the traffic in your area and the weather conditions throughout the year. If you live in an area where the risk of damaging your car is higher than usual, spending a little extra on new car replacement insurance might be a good idea.
  • Your vehicle depreciates more quickly than others. Some vehicles, such as expensive sports cars, depreciate more quickly than others. Before deciding to get new car replacement insurance, you should find out how much you’re likely to lose if you total your car within the first year or two.

New Car Replacement Insurance vs. Guaranteed Asset Protection Insurance

GAP insurance, which stands for guaranteed asset protection, is somewhat similar to new car replacement insurance in the sense that it protects you financially if you total your car. GAP insurance pays the difference between your car’s diminished value and your remaining loan or lease balance. It doesn’t apply to cars that are owned outright.

For example, if you finance or lease a $40,000 car and get into an accident a few months later, your collision coverage may pay out $35,000, but your outstanding debt is $37,000. GAP insurance covers that $2,000 difference. You’d still have no car, but at least you wouldn’t owe money on a car you no longer have.

In the same scenario, new car replacement insurance would allow you to get your initial $40,000 back and replace your vehicle. However, you would probably have to put some of that money toward paying off your lease or loan if you didn’t have GAP coverage.

New Car Replacement Insurance vs. Better Car Replacement Insurance

Better car replacement insurance is a similar product that appeals to drivers with slightly older vehicles. If you drive a car that’s a few years old and total it, your insurance carrier will reimburse you with the estimated value of the same make and model but one year newer and with 15,000 fewer miles.

It’s usually a good idea to use better car replacement insurance as a follow-up to new car replacement insurance when your car gets older and doesn’t fit the criteria for the latter. This way, if a collision occurs and you total your car, you can at least get a better replacement.

You May Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *